On the Komatsu HB215-1 excavator, energy in the capacitor (lower left) can be sent to either the swing motor or to the generator motor to help the engine accelerate as engine assist.
Photo credit: Image provided by Komatsu
High fuel prices, competitive bidding for available work and emissions compliance place extraordinary pressures on your business. Increasing productivity and cutting costs can mean the difference between success and mere survival. Recently, several manufacturers have developed innovative equipment solutions that may just give you that competitive advantage.
New hybrid and battery technologies allow equipment to capture kinetic energy that was previously wasted as heat or, in some cases, cut or totally eliminate diesel fuel consumption. While this technology may require a higher initial investment, the payback comes in terms of increased productivity, the ability to work on regulated jobsites and reduced operating costs. Let’s take a look at some of the latest innovations.
AC puts more power to the ground
Caterpillar has increased the operational efficiency of its D7-size dozers by incorporating electric drive components. “The D7E is not only more powerful, it is much faster than its predecessors,” says Sam Meeker, track-type tractor and track-type loader applications. “There is no torque converter to absorb the power, so it is transferred directly to the track.”
The secret to its performance lies with alternating current (AC) technology. “The AC power has very quick response, amazing amounts of torque and low drivetrain losses,” says Meeker. “In addition to being efficient, it is also adapted very well to the dozer. The weight of the machine did not change vs. the D7R powershift tractor, but the balance is better due to the drivetrain components being spaced differently.”
Efficiencies result from being able to finely tune the Caterpillar C9 engine. “The engine can be tuned to run in a narrower band, and a lower RPM band at that,” notes Meeker. “Also, the efficiencies of the electric drivetrain are significant and likely contribute more to the overall efficiency than just the engine. We can basically produce only the power needed, rather than too much or too little.”
Hydraulic efficiency has also been improved. “The hydraulic valves have been located closer to where they do their work — forward for the dozer and rear for the ripper or winch,” says Meeker. Performance and speed have been improved, along with performance with grade control technologies. “In addition, we have eliminated many lines, hoses and leak points for better long-term durability.”
Maintenance demands have decreased, as well. “Since the transmission does not have clutches, and there are fewer bearings, there are less contaminants in the oil,” explains Meeker. “This allows us to have less powertrain oil and increase the interval time for both the oil and filter. The significance compared to overall owning and operating cost is not huge, but every little bit helps. The long-term owning and operating cost is much less, since the components last much longer and are effectively designed for the life of the tractor.”
As you might expect, the price tag for the D7E is higher than for the conventional D7R. However, the higher initial purchase price is quickly recouped. “An average customer will see payback in 2.5 years,” says Meeker. “It will be even shorter as fuel prices increase.”
Hybrid options boost efficiency
John Deere set CONEXPO-CON/AGG visitors abuzz with two hybrid-electric wheel loaders — the 644K and 944K. Each utilizes a unique hybrid solution.
The 644K will be the first out of the gate, with a target date of 2012. It will be sold alongside the conventional torque converter model. “This is a transmission option on the 644,” says Kevin Funke, engineering manager, loaders. An electric generator and motor power the transmission and axles. “We are driving it through a traditional drivetrain system.”
The component layout leverages the conventional design. Coming off the engine is a driveshaft that runs to a gearbox, on which is mounted a generator and hydraulic pumps that run the front linkage. A cable runs from the generator to the Power Electronic Box mounted beneath the platform, with power cables extending from there to an electric motor.
“The electric motor is driving a three-speed powershift transmission,” Funke notes. “Conventional driveshafts and axles run the rest of the machine. The major components on the system — the gearbox and transmission — are all mounting up in the same general location as the torque converter transmission.”
The 644K electric drive option offers increased fuel efficiency vs. a lock-up torque converter system. According to Funke, during low-speed, high-torque conditions, such as loading the bucket in a pile, the torque converter is slipping and burning energy. “With the electric drive system, you are not wasting that energy,” he asserts.
In addition, a lot of energy is wasted during machine reversals with a traditional torque converter. With the hybrid system, that energy is converted to electrical energy that is then used to help raise the boom.
“So, as you are running a truck loading cycle, doing the reversals, the motor is turning into a generator,” says Funke. “And while you are raising the boom to approach the truck, that electrical energy is getting converted to hydraulic energy to assist with raising the boom.”
He adds, “It is a combination of minimizing the torque converter losses, plus conversion of that kinetic energy into electric energy to assist with raising the boom.”
The 944K is a new size loader for John Deere with a unique hybrid approach. It uses independent electric motors to drive the wheels — a fuel-saving approach. “We are measuring a 20% to 25% improvement in fuel efficiency compared to a torque converter system,” says Funke.
Wheel speeds and articulation angle are measured and used to manage tire slip. “Because we are individually controlling each of the wheels, we are managing tire slip, which is a big improvement in tire wear,” Funke relates. “That is a really big deal on that size machine.”
The conventional drivetrain in a wheel loader requires a high amount of energy to generate high push forces. “We are eliminating all of the traditional drivetrain,” says Funke. “You don’t have the transmission. You don’t have all of those drivelines. With electric drives, we can have tremendous control of very high forces. It is like having an automatic differential lock all of the time.”
Another advantage of independent wheel drive is the 15,000- to 20,000-hour component life. “We can rotate front motors and final drives with the rear motors and final drives,” says Funke. Most wear usually occurs on the front axles of a wheel loader. “Rotating the components levels out the wear and extends the overall life of the drivetrain.”
Harnessing wasted energy
Often, hybrid technology works by recycling energy that would otherwise be wasted as heat rejection. Such is the case with the Komatsu Hybrid HB215LC-1 excavator.
Typically, there is a lot of energy lost as the excavator swings back and forth on the undercarriage. “The electric swing motor recovers energy during each swing brake,” says Armando Najera, excavator product manager. “This is the basis for regeneration — harnessing energy that would otherwise go unused.” This energy is stored in the capacitor to be used when needed.
“The energy in the capacitor can be sent to either the swing motor or to the generator motor to help the engine accelerate as engine assist,” says Najera. “This allows the hybrid to quickly respond to hydraulic power demands using saved energy, thus providing an efficiency advantage over conventional machines.”
Komatsu proprietary machine control logic also contributes to fuel savings. “The hybrid has a different approach to engine speed management during operation,” notes Najera. “An extremely low engine idle speed helps reduce fuel consumption in between work cycles. The engine assist technology helps the engine and hydraulic system quickly reach the necessary speed to match hydraulic demand without delay.
“In a conventional machine, such rapid recovery from idle or hydraulic load is not as efficient,” he continues. “But with the hybrid system, the engine ramps up to the required engine speed based on the hydraulic demand and other inputs.”
There are other benefits, such as reduced noise. “Due to the engine speed management and electrical engine assist, the engine spends less time at high rpms, making its quieter operation ideal for noise sensitive areas,” says Najera. “It is impressive to be near the machine and be able to speak with a normal tone, especially during the swing cycle.”
The Komatsu hybrid excavator has an already proven track record. “Worldwide, there are over 700 machines in operation that have logged over a million hours of operation,” Najera points out. “Some of the first machines sold now have over 13,000 hours with the original components and continue in operation.”
He adds, “The hybrid system was designed with long-term durability in mind. The hybrid components utilize a separate cooling circuit. This adds to the system’s long-term reliability.”
Najera acknowledges there is a premium for the hybrid technology. “But the current pace of rising fuel prices and other elements such as environmental regulations and initiatives put the ROI quantifiable in many of today’s and future operating budgets. We’ve seen company initiatives that are beginning to recognize the application of green technology into a fleet, and we’ve received feedback that the presence of a hybrid on a jobsite is turning heads and drawing attention.”
Battery power replaces internal combustion
Takeuchi takes the electrical concept even further with its TB117e compact excavator, eliminating the internal combustion engine altogether. The all-electric machine, shown at CONEXPO-CON/AGG as a concept model, is powered by a lithium-ion battery.
“Li-ion technology has made great strides due in part to the automotive industry,” says David Caldwell, training/product manager. “The TB117e is able to work up to six hours on a full charge.”
Full recharging takes approximately 12 hours using 110 volts, or about six hours using 200 to 250 volts. The production model will feature plug-and-run capability should the runtime need to be extended.
Since it is weather resistant, the TB117e can be utilized both indoors and out. However, it is especially suited to interior applications.
“What really makes it unique is the zero exhaust emissions,” says Caldwell. “This is attractive to states with increasingly tight emissions standards, and to contractors who often need a machine that can operate inside a building. The TB117e is ideal for working in schools, residential areas, hospitals, malls, food/grain production facilities, inside demolition projects, etc. Thanks to its low noise levels, it can start to work earlier and work later, providing greater productivity without disturbing others.”
The TB117e offers the same level of performance as the conventional TB017. It boasts an operating weight of 3,792 lbs., features a 7-ft. maximum dig depth, a maximum reach of 12 ft. 5.6 in. and a bucket breakout force of 4,079 lbs.
“You don’t sacrifice anything,” says Caldwell. “What you give up are the emissions, [the need] to refuel it daily and the maintenance associated with the engine. Because it is electrically powered, a battery pack and electric motors drive a traditional hydraulic system that can be maintained and serviced by mechanics familiar with hydraulic systems.”
Clearly, hybrid and electric technologies are quickly becoming a reality. While the initial purchase price is typically higher, the long-term prospect for these machines to increase your bottom line is promising. This makes it worth watching, especially as fuel prices continue to climb.