Pick Trailers to Last a Lifetime

With increased steel prices, equipment trailers have become a major investment. "Today, you have to pay more attention to the details because you are investing $75,000, $100,000 or $200,000," says Jim Ladner, national sales manager, Landoll Corp. "It isn't like 20 years ago when they were a third the price."

The decisions you make now can have consequences well into the future. "In most cases, we have life cycle on our product of 15 to 18 years," says Ladner. "If you look back 18 years, what did the equipment look like? Keep in mind that the equipment in the construction field always tends to grow and get heavier. You need to look down the road and buy a trailer that is probably more than you really need, but will do the job for you tomorrow."

Ladner adds that no single trailer is likely to haul all of your equipment. You should designate trailers to groups of equipment suited to that trailer design.

As equipment designs change, it may also be more of a challenge to get by with the trailers you have used in the past. Fred McClure, engineering manager, Eager Beaver Trailers cites its 10-ton tag trailer as a unique example. "When we started building it almost 30 years ago, the typical backhoe that was put on it weighed 14,000 lbs. Today, the same series of backhoe literally grew in weight from 14,000 lbs. to closer to 18,000 lbs."

However, many contractors resist going up to a 12-ton trailer since they have to pay Federal Excise Tax (FET). "The private contractor is still trying to hold onto the 10-ton trailer and not pay the FET on it," says McClure. "He has to be very critical on how he loads it so he is not overloading the tires and axles."

Understand ratings

It is important to understand trailer ratings and industry standards when comparing equipment trailers. "There is an important balance between the tare weight, the weight of the trailer and its ultimate load capacity," says Ladner. "If you build a trailer too light, it may not be able to haul the payload. But if you go too heavy, then you lessen the legal payload it can handle."

Determining the trailer weight is rather straightforward. "On the serial tag, you normally have the GVW," says Butch Odegaard, national accounts, Trail King. "That gives you the capacity of the trailer plus the payload. You can subtract the capacity from the payload and that will give you what the trailer weighs."

But there are often trade-offs between weight and durability. According to Odegaard, with lighter trailers, you have to keep the safety factor in mind. Trail King builds to Truck Trailer Manufacturer (TTMA) guidelines, which include a 2 to 2.5 times safety factor. "There are some trailer manufacturers that don't live by that safety factor," he points out. Their trailers can be constructed lighter because they are forfeiting the safety factor.

In addition, you need to make sure the load is compatible with the trailer's concentrated weight rating. "The contractor has to fully understand what he is going to haul — what it weighs and how much deck space it is going to consume," says Ladner.

The weight over a given area determines the necessary concentrated weight rating. "If the contractor has a forklift that weighs 10,000 lbs. in 10 ft., he needs to know the frame is going to hold it."

Not every manufacturer lists the concentrated load factor the same, and some manufacturers do not list it at all. "Landoll rates its trailers within a 10 ft. area," says Ladner. Some manufacturers rate trailers at 16 ft. Make sure you are making an "apples to apples" comparison. "If my trailer frame is strong enough to hold 35 tons at 10 ft. and theirs is strong enough to hold 35 tons at 16 ft., theirs is a weaker frame."

Next, you need to consider how the trailer will be loaded. The entire GVWR is not intended to be carried by the tires and axles. A portion of the weight is actually assigned to the hitch. Deck length and axle placement need to allow the weight to be distributed so the weight at the hitch and over the axles is within acceptable limits.

You may also run across speed ratings. This is an area for caution. Some tires are rated for higher loads at a reduced speed. Even though federal law permits placing a dual rating on the trailer, McClure notes that many states do not recognize these ratings. So this is something you might want to avoid. He adds, "In most of our applications, the tire rating exceeds the axle capacity."

"I think the dual rating is kind of misleading to the customer," comments Odegaard. Dynamic forces on the trailer are greater at higher speeds. "The capacity of the trailer does go up at slower speeds, but we will not rate it that way. We rate ours at highway speeds."

Ladner agrees, adding, "If the road is safe at 70 mph, then that driver is going to want to travel safely at 70 mph. When you start to throw restriction in, then typically you get customer abuse on the product."

Finally, you have to realize that trailer ratings are absolute. "Operators sometimes think, ‘I am only going to [exceed the rating] once a month,' " says Ladner. "It is just not safe when you exceed the ratings on the trailer, truck or piece of equipment."

By moving to a larger trailer that will handle the most demanding jobs, you will actually get longer life. "Even though you might invest a little more money up front, you will get the return back with the service out of that product," says Ladner.

Trailer weight is not as critical as load capacity. "For example, a lot of people will buy our 20-ton tag trailer, but will only be putting from 10 to 15 tons on it," says McClure. "They can probably put only 17 tons on it legally before they are exceeding legal requirements of the tandem on the trailer."

The same trend occurs with lowboy trailers. "People will buy our 50-ton trailer, but they will put anywhere from 70,000 to 100,000 lbs. on it," says McClure. "They will have multiple pieces of equipment, and they buy the slightly bigger trailer just to have a trailer that could handle anything."

Deck materials expand

Oak and Apitong are traditional deck materials. "Oak is still the most common, replenishable wood you can put on it," says McClure. "Apitong is a significant upgrade. It is pre-dried and it doesn't warp."

But there are advancements taking place in alternate materials. "We are trying to get into some different kinds of decking for trailers," says Odegaard. "One is called Rumber; it is a rubber compound decking. Hopefully, with tracked equipment, the decks will last a little bit longer."

Another option is a bamboo composite. "We are testing both of these alternatives to Apitong," says Ladner.

The goal is to increase the deck life to more closely match the trailer life. "When you are talking about equipment that will last 15 to 20 years, if you stay with Apitong, you might be talking about two to four deck replacements," says Ladner. "Rumber is in the same 15- to 20-year life cycle. So the decking might last the life of the trailer."

Low cg and load angle

Low load angles benefit all equipment. This has led to innovations such as the traveling (or sliding) axle trailer, which was introduced in 1970. "It has been well accepted in the construction industry as a transport for 80% of the equipment used," says Ladner. "You can load low-clearance equipment really well, and you can haul multiple pieces on a deck that is up to 53 ft. long."

"The big advantage to the sliding axle is load angle," says Odegaard. "You get a much better loading angle than you do with a beavertail or a tilt bed."

However, the center of gravity (cg) is always a concern when moving equipment. "It makes the load a lot more stable and it is safer for the equipment operator to load if you keep the cg down," says Odegaard.

While tag and sliding axle trailers are popular with many contractors, there are issues with equipment that has a high cg. "With a tag trailer, you are loading above the tires," says Odegaard. "So you are probably starting out at 3 ft. high."

This is where the detachable gooseneck trailer really shines, since it lowers equipment to the ground. But some contractors are also discovering the benefits of combining the low cg of a detachable gooseneck with low load angles.

For example, about five years ago, Eager Beaver introduced a detachable trailer initially earmarked for paving equipment. It had a much lower approach angle in the front. "We are selling a good number of those trailers, and not just to the paving industry," says McClure. They are being used to haul multiple equipment, including excavators and graders that can climb the steeper angles of a regular trailer. "They find it is just much nicer to load on these lower profile trailers."

Features separate premium trailers

Many features separate the premium equipment trailers on the market, including the use of high-tensile strength steels. "The higher the tensile steel, the less you need to carry the payload," says Odegaard. These steels can range from 100,000- to 130,000-psi yield strength.

But it takes engineering expertise to properly apply these steels. "We use a blend of materials," says Ladner. "We don't build them all out of 100,000-psi yield material because the higher tensile steels are more flexible. You can't have a trailer that is too rigid or too soft. The thickness of the flanges and heights of the web are a key part. It does take strong engineering to get the beams of those trailers built properly."

Material selection impacts the life of the trailer. Therefore, Eager Beaver trailers are somewhat "hybrids". "We do use high-tensile steels. There is everything from Grade 80 to T-1 in our trailer beams," McClure states. Consider the lowboy trailers. "Many of our competitors are using T-1 for the flanges; we use Grade 80. Even though it is a little bit less in actual tensile strength, we feel it is a better material. It is a little more ductile material. It gives us durability."

Beyond the steel used, there are several component advancements that can reduce maintenance. LED lighting is becoming a standard on many premium trailers. "We feel that it gives the customer better life," says Ladner. "It is a higher quality light."

Outboard hub-piloted wheels can also minimize service requirements. "All of our trailers have hub-piloted wheels now," says McClure. "When you pull a brake drum off to work on the brakes, you don't have to pull the hub and replace the seals."

Centralized lube systems are another time saver. "We can lubricate any grease zerk from a single point," says Ladner. "It makes the service of our trailers easy for the mechanic."

Continuous tire inflation systems promise to not only reduce maintenance, but extend tire life. "It is one of the more popular options that has just come about in the last couple of years," says Ladner. "Load ratings are set at a certain pressure on your tires. If you maintain that, you have proper tire load capacity. If you maintain the tire pressure, you minimize heat buildup, which just destroys tires. There are documented studies that show tremendous payback on continuous tire inflation systems."

Another recent advancement is in tag trailer suspensions. "We use a torsion axle, which is a rubber-mounted spring inside the axle that simulates air ride as close as it can," says Ladner.

Eager Beaver has even seen an increase in the number of air suspension systems used on tag trailers, although the overall number still remains low. "We happen to offer a 25-ton with a third lift axle that is air ride," says McClure. The axles behind it are spring mounted. "It is a nice feature to be able to run around as a tandem when you only need a tandem, rather than have those three axles on the ground all of the time."

Some 20-ton tag trailers are built with an all air suspension system. "There is significant cost to do that," says McClure. "But it significantly helps the load approach angle because you can drop that 5 in. and get a much better approach angle on your ramp."

There are several other items separating a premium trailer from the low-cost units available. Among them are the paints and coatings used, the types of jacks, suspension options, etc.

"Look at the quality that goes into the trailer," advises Odegaard. "Don't always look at price. Look at the workmanship in the trailer and the engineering, as well as the resale."

Loading