ForConstructionPros.com

Article

  

Features

Updated: July 8th, 2008 05:26 PM GMT-05:00

Gas vs. Diesel

Recent developments may affect light-and medium-duty powerplant choices.

Ford Super-Duty truck
Over 90% of Ford Super-Duty owners use their vehicles for towing applications.
Triton engine
Ford offers gas engines, such as this 6.8-liter Triton, for customers who don't need the torque of a diesel engine.
Powerstroke diesel engine
The Powerstroke diesel is the workhorse of Ford's truck line.
General Motors truck
General Motors gives its medium-duty customers a choice of engines.
Duramax 7800 diesel engine
The Duramax 7800 diesel engine supplies the torque needed for towing heavy loads.
Vortec 8100 engine
The Vortec 8100, a gas alternative for medium-duty customers.
HEMI engine
The HEMI is Dodge's solution for customers who require a gas engine.
Cummins diesel engine
The Cummins diesel provides reliable pulling power for the Dodge Ram. About 85% of these vehicles are equipped with the Cummins engine.
Dodge Ram
Dodge Ram

Curt Bennink
By Curt Bennink
Senior Field Editor

The 2007 model year ushers in a new era of diesel engine technology. The previously established image of diesel engines as noisy and dirty will be radically altered as new NOx and particulate emissions standards set by the EPA go into effect.

Every diesel-powered vehicle that operates on the road will be affected. "If it has four wheels and it runs on public roads, it is going to have to have a diesel particulate filter," says Steve Matsil, vehicle chief engineer - medium-duty commercial trucks and full-size vans, General Motors.

In addition, increased use of exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) — with larger EGR coolers, closed crankcase ventilation and more complex ECUs and sensors to control regeneration of the particulate filter — means the diesel engine has become a lot more sophisticated.

But the basic fundamental advantages of the diesel engine remain. They offer a longer service life and, under certain conditions, you can see up to a 30% increase in fuel economy. This is largely due to the thermal efficiencies of a diesel engine vs. a gasoline engine. Diesels run a compression ratio of 18:1 to 20:1. A typical gas engine will run 10:1. That difference translates into huge thermal efficiency gains.

And while gas engines often boast higher horsepower ratings, it is the torque that is important when towing heavy loads. Torque is the twisting force that determines how much load can be moved. It is hard to beat a diesel engine when it comes to torque ratings.

1 2 3 4 5 6 next
E-mail This StoryE-mail Article Print This StoryPrinter Friendly